"Antarctic Ice Has Grown Again – But This Does Not Back Melt Trend "

 By: ShiengaVisualStorytelling2025



Source: The Guardian 

 

1. Does the image accurately represent the headline’s message?

Partly. The image shows a dramatic iceberg calving (breaking off), which reflects the ongoing ice melt aspect of the headline. However, it does not visually represent the part about ice growth, creating an incomplete view of the full message.

2. What emotions does the image evoke?

It evokes urgency and concern, as the large chunk of ice breaking into the sea is dramatic and suggests environmental instability and climate change.

3. Is the image manipulated or biased?

Not manipulated, but visually biased. It highlights melting and collapse, which could emphasize alarm over balance, potentially skewing viewer perception away from the growth aspect mentioned in the headline.

4. How does composition affect storytelling?

The tight framing on the falling ice, combined with the sharp lighting and clear focus on the impact with water, creates a powerful and emotionally charged moment that focuses the viewer’s attention on destruction rather than change over time.

5. Does the image add depth to the story or simply reinforce the headline?

It reinforces part of the headline (the melt), but does not add nuance about the temporary or localized growth. It helps dramatize the story but lacks full balance.

6. Would a different image change the reader’s perception of the news?

Yes. An image showing ice expansion, satellite data, or a time-lapse comparison might offer a more balanced view and support the headline's complex message better.

7. How does the image compare to others covering the same story?

Similar stories often use before-and-after comparisons or scientific visualizations. This image is more visually striking but less informative in terms of scientific context.

8. Is the image culturally or politically significant?

Yes. Climate imagery like this often carries political weight, as it can influence public opinion and policy debate on climate change. Though the image itself is neutral, its selection over others reflects a societal focus on environmental urgency.

Conclusion (optional for class use):

The image powerfully shows the melting aspect of Antarctic changes but lacks balance in representing the headline’s full meaning. It is emotionally effective but visually partial, underlining the importance of thoughtful image selection in climate reporting.

#UniMAC-IFT # #IVST 2025 #Group News Analysis 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

#Shienga Storytelling #UniMAC IFT Individual News Stories And Analysis

Image
"Florida Dad Dies After Helping Save His Daughter From Drowning On Father's Day" Source: The Guardian  Antwon Wilson was with his two children at a Fort Lauderdale beach when he saw them struggling for their lives in the water. Father's Day is a memorable day for the celebration of heroism portrayed by fathers. Who would have imagined that on such an epic day, a man will bring to bear such an act of bravery and sacrifice, bringing to the fore, the very essence of the ceremonial day itself? On a day when fathers around the world were being honoured and celebrated, a young father in Florida chose to write his legacy with love, courage—and his final breath. Antwon Wilson, a 33-year-old father of two, met his untimely death at the shores of Fort Lauderdale in the United States on Father’s Day, after bravely saving his daughter from drowning. It was supposed to be a simple family outing—sun, laughter, and waves. Mr. Wilson had taken his children to the beach near B Ocean R...
Read more

ABRONYE DC FACES PARTY PROBE FOR DEFYING NPP GUIDELINES

Image
DIANA AZURE  ABRONYE DC FACES PARTY PROBE FOR  By Azure Diana June 28 2025 Source : Adom Online         DEFYING NPP GUIDELINES  The New Patriotic Party (NPP) has taken formal action against its Bono Regional Chairman,  Kwame Baffoe , popularly known as  Abronye DC , by referring him to the party’s  Disciplinary Committee . This follows what the party described as  “unguarded public comments”  and a breach of directives issued by its National Council    . In a statement released on  Tuesday, June 24, 2025 , General Secretary  Justin Kodua Frimpong  disclosed that the decision was taken during a meeting of the  National Steering Committee     . The party, however, did not reveal specific details of the alleged misconduct, only confirming that Abronye’s actions “contravened internal guidelines designed to safeguard unity ahead of the party’s upcoming presidential primaries”...
Read more

Shienga Visual Storytelling Individual News Analysis Story1 #Visual Storytelling #IVS2025 #UniMAC-IFT June 15, 2025

 Individual News Analysis Story 1 News Agency: The Guardian  Date: Wed June 11th, 2025. 17: 13 CEST. 1. The image really does represent the headline. In the photo we can see black Africans in a typical rural setting with a bag of rice on a scale having a USAID name and logo boldly inscribed on it. Although the USAID does come in diverse means such as financial grants, technical assistances and advisory support, majority comes in the form of food supplies, medical items and other miscellaneous to usually deprived communities, refugees and conflict areas. This particular photo highlights one of such places. 2. There's a sad, and crestfallen look on the individual beneficiaries around. With the Trump administration's plan to cut of subsequent aid to the continent, some worried concerns can be observed on the faces of the people standing around the supplies. The emotions depicted here might not necessarily connect with the US government's plan of scraping the support and might ...
Read more